Dear residents of KwaZulu
Natal,
I was struck by a story aired last week
by the SABC television as part of their evening business news
bulletin. After a coy introduction suggesting that allegations
exist to the effect that the policy of black economic
empowerment (BEE) has not always been broad-based enough to
benefit those who need genuine empowerment, the SABC proudly
presented an interesting story.
Barloworld, a reputable trucking
enterprise, is participating in an empowerment deal involving a
R20-million fund which allows truckers to take ownership of the
company’s trucks. The idea is to allow Barloworld’s former
employees to become fully-fledged business partners. This is
commendable in that it translates into real economic empowerment
for the previously disadvantaged.
At the same time, the story, as
presented by the SABC, betrays a guilty conscience. The
government, whose views the public service broadcaster promotes,
is clearly aware of BEE’s unpopularity amongst the poor who are
waiting, largely in vain, for tangible signs of economic
empowerment.
The story gives the impression that the
SABC is frantically searching for any example of broad-based BEE
to forestall criticisms that the policy only benefits an
ANC-aligned elite – which is the plain truth. In doing so, it
watches out for every crumb about to fall off the table laden
with a sumptuous feast.
Quite frankly, R20-million is a drop in
the sea of billions transferred to ANC bigwigs in BEE deals in
the mining industry alone. How many trucks can be purchased for
R20-million and how many truckers will benefit in the end? Will
it be enough for an evening story on the national television?
If the government is looking to redeem
itself – with abundant help from the SABC – it will have to do a
lot more than empower a handful of truckers. The BEE deals need
to bypass big consortia and reach previously disadvantaged
individuals directly to make the kind of difference we all are
striving for.
Dr Lionel Mtshali MPP
Leader of the Official
Opposition
Contact: Dr Lionel Mtshali, 083 256
4902