Around the globe health care has similar
challenges, and whether it is Democrats under Obama or
Socialists under Motlante, the IFP believes that governments
must opt for solutions that work.
Appropriate solutions require the right
questions.
- What constitutes good health?
- How do we provide all citizens with
health care?
- Keep costs down?
- Improve efficiency in state
facilities?
- Curb the greed and exploitive
practices of the private sector?
- Train and maintain standards of good
doctors and nurses?
- Prevent corruption in the health
industry?
- Achieve the millennium development
goals, reduce infant mortality and increase longevity?
The specifics in South Africa relate
largely to AIDS, TB, malaria and of late cholera. Our public
sector is under pressure of collapse and in the private sector,
people are paying more often for less.
How to respond?
A healthy lifestyle is the cornerstone
of preventive, primary health care, to promote physical,
emotional and spiritual balance. As in the East, let's organise
daily work outs in public spaces; switch off TV and mobile
phones and switch on sports, music and art in schools and in our
homes. Immediately ban Transfats as proposed in my Bill agreed
to by the department and the private members legislative
committee. They are artificially produced for commercial gain
and contribute to heart disease, diabetes, weight gain and
cancer.
When it comes to treatment, register
conventional doctors, homeopaths, acupuncturists, chiropractors,
naturopaths, ayurvedic and Chinese doctors through a single,
independent, democratically elected Medical Council.
Draw health practitioners to underserved
areas through incentives and open more nursing colleges in
partnership with the private sector.
All other therapies of holistic health
modalities should form part of an Holistic Healers Association.
A traditional healers' council should deal only with herbalists,
surgeons and birth attendants, not abaprophete and sangomas who
work on a metaphysical dimension and cannot be monitored or
controlled.
Ensure that at national and regional
level, formal structures exist to provide for co operation and
collaboration between all these health professionals.
This should follow through into working
groups that tackle issues like AIDS, TB, malaria and cholera
together regionally and locally.
Collaborative research between
traditional, complementary and conventional practitioners should
be encouraged and funded.
For years we have watched impractical
policies fail us. The most damaging of these is the centralised
model, with unfunded mandates, bureaucratic conditional grants
and the idea that one size fits all and one seat of power can
decree accordingly.
Hence, the current system, which is
confusing and lacks accountability should be decentralised and
simplified.
Let Provincial and Local Governments
make decisions, control funds and choose priorities.
Let discipline be meted out close to
where doctors and nurses work.
Build stronger health districts and
improve coordination between hospitals, clinics and mobiles in
rural areas and between these, schools, and local police.
Coordinate responses at the practical
and implementation level and build functional integrated
information systems. for tracking numbers of vulnerable
children, people tested, diagnosed and on treatment, or applying
for grants.
Remove constraints that prevent
districts, municipalities and hospitals from negotiating
partnerships with the private sector. Districts should also work
closely with NGOs and international donors. Currently most NGO
funding is politically motivated, weakening the impact it has on
the major epidemics in South Africa.
Private Public Partnerships (PPP's)
Put one of the best private health care
systems in the world at the service of one of the worst public
ones through PPP's that go to best bidders and not best
buddies.
Contract the private sector to run
mobile services in rural communities and manage clinics or
hospital wards.
Appoint independent health ombudsmen or
standards compliance bodies that ensure minimum standards
everywhere. Charters are no substitute for accountability.
Do away with licensing according to
NEED. It is subjective and open to patronage and corruption.
Rather draw health workers to underserved areas through
incentives which achieve more than coercion.
HIV TB
The greatest burden on public hospitals
is HIV and TB. The IFP suggests many changes to the way those
diseases are handled.
Let us treat HIV like an ordinary
disease without need for special secrecy provisions. Testing
should be the norm with an opt out provision for those who
refuse it.
Change the focus of rights from the
right to privacy to the right of non-discrimination. No persons
should lose their jobs because they have HIV or receive a lesser
chronic medical benefit. If they die of HIV they must receive
full death benefit and full life payout.
But, the excessive focus on privacy adds
to the culture of denial and gives people the sense that HIV is
something to be ashamed of. HIV should be regarded as
commonplace as TB, diabetes or hypertension.
How do we reduce medical costs?
Free choice that engenders competition,
minimum controls that ensure fairness and vigorous policing are
the keys to effective health funding at the lowest possible
cost.
We should implement a form of social
health insurance, with everyone who works paying a percentage
towards a medical scheme of their choice. Government should
offer a low cost scheme for people who can't afford the current
private medical schemes. It should enforce caps on medical
scheme administration fees, which enable schemes to accumulate
and hide huge profits.
In hospitals, let government hospitals
retain profits and establish private wards. Let government bring
prices down by bulk purchasing of private hospital services to
registered, government-funded patients paid for per day or per
capita or per procedure.
Where medicines are concerned, enforce
transparency along the entire chain of medicine supplies so that
similar discounts are offered for bulk purchases without
prejudice or favour, but encourage discounting and competition.
Put a reasonable cap on retail mark ups,
but allow competition on prices and let any store sell medicines
through a pharmacist. Contract pharmacies to provide chronic
medication to registered patients.
This above framework would remove
perverse incentives and contradictory regulations. It would
prevent the private sector misleading the public through
marketing and the public sector doing so through populism. It
would provide a far stronger health system to cope with
HIV/AIDS, TB, STD's, cholera, vulnerable children and our
mushrooming population of mentally disturbed persons.
It would help us face current
challenges.
Contact:
Dr Ruth Rabinowitz MP
011 802 1826 or 082 579 3698