Mr Robert Mugabe’s inauguration in Harare yesterday,
if it was not deadly serious, would go down in
history as the most deranged piece of political
satire ever.
As the IFP participants in the previous observer
missions to monitor elections in Zimbabwe did in the
past, every observer mission, including those of
SADC and the PAP, have rejected the result of this
fraudulent election. In no way at all did it reflect
the will of the people. The IFP supports the calls
from SADC and the Pan African Parliament observer
missions that conditions be put in place for the
holding of a free and fair run-off as soon as
possible. This should be made clear to Mr Mugabe in
no uncertain terms when he arrives in Egypt today.
An IFP member of parliament, Suzanne Vos, has
reported to me that she personally witnessed
appalling intimidation and violence in the various
provinces of Zimbabwe where she had been assigned to
observe not only the Presidential run-off but
various Parliamentary by-elections. The crimes
committed by the Zanu-PF thugs can only be
classified in the same category as Stalin’s
bloodthirsty crazed lieutenants in the former Soviet
Union for their wickedness.
Ms Vos visited homes where elderly people (in one
case a retired teacher and his wife) had been
brutally assaulted because the husband was a
supporter of the MDC.
On another occasion she witnessed a truck loaded
with ZANU PF thugs openly assault MDC supporters
after they had left a meeting held on the private
property of an MDC Councillor. Even though two of
the thugs present were identified as being the sons
of a former ZANU PF Senator (who had also been
identified as being among the assailants in the
attack on the retired teacher and his wife a few
days previously) no arrests were made even though Ms
Vos reported her eye-witness accounts to the
police.
After the closing of the polls, Ms Vos was situated
alone at a polling station at a rural school where
the MDC had requested the presence of PAP
observers. Other members in her team in that area
had spread out to cover the counting as much as
possible. During the day, while visiting 18 polling
stations in that Ward, MDC party agents had pleaded
with the PAP observers to "protect" them as they
feared being murdered on their way home. Several
showed Ms Vos bruises on their bodies inflicted in
previous "beatings" by persons they said were "War
Veterans".
Minutes before the ballot boxes were to be opened a
group of men silently entered the polling station
blocking the door and forming a menacing line in
front of the election officials (who consisted of
the principal of the school and various teachers).
Their presence was clearly unlawful and alarming.
Showing considerable courage, Ms Vos said the chief
electoral officer exorted the men to leave and
quoted electoral law as to who was allowed to be in
the polling station during counting. He then
pointed to the presence of the Pan African
Parliament observer. The men then slowly left.
Ms Vos was told the men were "War Veterans" and
"Green Bombers" who had been terrorising residents
in the area.
Voters were told that "Operation Red Finger" meant
they had to vote (and show the red dye mark
indicating they had done so) and then report to the
home of a local "War Veteran" nearby not only
showing that they had voted but they also had to
write down the serial number on their ballot paper
on their hands.
Ms Vos personally took the terrified MDC party
agents away from the polling station to a place
where they said they would hide - an area in which
the burned out houses of MDC supporters were
scattered throughout the township. The party agents
told Ms Vos they had not been able to sleep in their
homes for many weeks. The same stories of
intimidation and destruction of property were
repeated to PAP observers throughout the country and
is reflected in the PAP Observer Mission's interim
report.
Ms Vos also reported that she had to personally
intervene with the commanding officer of the police
service in one area when MDC supporters trying to
hold a rally were threatened with the riot police -
even though they had obtained a High Court order
permitting them to hold the rally.
The previous day, in the same area, Ms Vos had
attended a rally held by President Robert Mugabe
where he told the audience that "a ball point pen
cannot compete with a bazooka... the MDC will never
rule this country..."
Ms Vos observed hate speech in the State-controlled
media against the leadership of the MDC and open
reporting of the war rhetoric which formed a golden
thread throughout the speeches of President Mugabe.
Together with her PAP colleagues she said she was
"simply shattered" by the suffering of the people of
Zimbabwe. Their dignity in the midst of their
plight was awe-inspiring. Ms Vos said she was not
once approached by beggars - when citizens saw her
PAP Observer Mission jacket they whispered: "Help
us, we are suffering... please help us" time and
time again.
She has described to me how people are starving.
The currency has been rendered literally worthless.
Citizens now describe their days starting from
zero... 0 0 1 means no breakfast, no lunch, a little
food at dinner. 1 0 0 means some breakfast and no
lunch or dinner.
But even as this appalling tragedy plays out, the
entire Mugabe phenomenon, cemented in stereotypes as
it is, is baffling for many. Some in our ruling
party – but thankfully not many now - and outside
lead us to believe that the fiercest opposition to
the Mugabe regime comes from the West, its alleged
stooges in the Movement for Democratic Change and
the dispossessed white farmers.
Today, I fear, few black South Africans would still
not acknowledge that the main victims of the
regime's misrule have increasingly been ordinary
black Zimbabweans, Shona and Ndebele, urban and
rural, even when an estimated three million of those
same black Zimbabweans live in exile among us. But
should we be surprised?
As our Northern neighbour slipped further into chaos
in the late 1990s — and I will not add to the
countless accounts of the litany of misrule and
disasters that have befallen this, former, African
jewel — Mr Mugabe's tottering government has been
buoyed by considerable populist support of the
rawest kind.
Mr Mugabe continues to cannily justify his
authoritarian misrule within a discourse of redress
for colonial injustice and imperialism. These
sentiments have resonated across Africa; large
swathes of which feel marginalised by the global
economy and its mighty supranational institutions
and remain wedded to the Marxist narrative of the
liberation struggle. When Zimbabwe rebuilds and
heals, as she will one day, we dare not ignore this
very real anger.
I watched Mr Mugabe's rousing welcome from many
African delegates at the World Development Summit in
Johannesburg in 2002 — the same conference at which
he launched a scathing attack on Tony Blair and
Britain's colonial past.
Two years later, at President Mbeki's inauguration,
he received an equally rapturous welcome from many
Africans as he stood, immaculately tailored and
ramrod straight, in the hot autumn sunshine.
On one occasion, I said that something had to be
done about Zimbabwe, at a SADC meeting in Angola.
This was after President Bush called on SADC to take
a decisive position. Not one minister agreed with me
in public, but several came up to me at teatime to
express their private agreement.
But let us not paint this as an exclusively
black-on-black error. The former National Party
government and human rights activists of all colours
took a long time before they started criticising Mr
Mugabe. World leaders were no different which is why
the Matabele massacres went almost unnoticed,
except, of course, by the Matabele! Their spilled
blood still cries out! Our failure to speak up for
Mr Mugabe’s victims has a long history and may have
contributed to his sense of impunity.
And this is it. This is where we all, on this side
of the Limpopo River, have blundered. This is where
lies our, South African, complicity in the failure
of Mr Mugabe's regime. We have let the situation in
Zimbabwe deteriorate so fast and so far without as
much as a word of concern. Yet, all along, those who
march to the drum of freedom have celebrated human
rights, promoted reconciliation, and respected the
rule of law and the political opposition.
Given these obvious double standards in my own
country, as an African, I feel I am obliged to take
some of the blame for Mr Mugabe's belief, fostered
by many ordinary Africans across our continent that
he is right to hang on — a truly tragic conflict of
loyalty.
Yet for all its past neglect — and the wild cheers
for Mr Mugabe —Africa’s stand on human rights is
changing and those who once seemed beyond the reach
of justice may find that public statements of
support from fellow leaders will evaporate once they
step down or are forced from power.
Accountability is on the march and better late than
never. Let us hope it comes soon to Zimbabwe.
Tonight, those of us who are believers in God or a
Higher Being, should not only bow our knee and say a
prayer for the Zimbabwean people, we should ask for
forgiveness for allowing such an evil to be
perpetrated on our borders.
God bless the people of Zimbabwe.
Yours sincerely,
Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi MP