Madame Speaker,
Today's debate on the Child Justice Bill
represents a milestone in the development of the South African
criminal justice system as it for the first time provides in
specific legislation for procedures to deal with children that have
come into conflict with the law.The underlying principles to the bill are
found in Section 28 of the Constitution which states, inter alia,
that "A child's best interests are of paramount importance in every
matter concerning the child", and more specifically, that children
should only be detained as a measure of last resort and then apart
from prisoners older than 18.
The Child Justice Bill provides the
legislative framework for special protection of children who have
come into conflict with the law.
The bill also gives effect to the
requirement that South Africa's accession to the UN Convention on
the Rights of the Child and the African Charter on the Rights and
Welfare of the Child must be taken up in our domestic law.
Madame Speaker,
The bill has been in the making for more
than ten years with the first steps taken as far back as May 1997,
and although it has taken a long time, the IFP shared the view of a
leading criminologist who said "it is better to have a bill, than no
bill at all".
The main objective of the bill is to provide
alternatives to the incarceration of children who committed less
serious criminal offences. The bill sets the age of 10 as the
minimum age for prosecution, while retaining the common law
presumption of incapacity for children under the age of 14.
Some of the alternative sentences envisaged
by the bill include:
Community-based sentences, including
rehabilitative diversion;
. Restorative justice sentences
. Correctional supervision
. Residential requirement sentences
. Residential facility sentences
I would like to concentrate on two of these
alternatives - diversion and restorative justice.
According to the Child Justice Alliance,
diversion is the "practise of referring a child away from formal
court procedures at any stage in the criminal justice process." It
is not a soft option, but seeks to change the child's pattern of
behaviour so that he or she understands the impact of their crime on
the community.
Restorative justice is not a new concept in
South Africa, and can be described as uniquely African as it
encapsulates some of the principles of Ubuntu. These include actions
such as an apology, restitution and reparation. Overall, the main
objective of restorative justice is to allow the offender to rejoin
the community and to prevent them from re-offending.
Madame Speaker,
The IFP supports the Child Justice Bill. It
provides legal certainty for dealing with children that have come
into conflict with the law, and provides them with a second chance
in life, while at the same time enabling them to take responsibility
for their actions without being incarcerated and exposed to hardened
criminals which sometimes can lead to a life of crime and not
rehabilitation.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
Ms Sybil Seaton
MP: 083 412 0075
Liezl van der Merwe: 083 611 7470